Adapting Board Roles for Ongoing Success

by Miriam April 9, 2024

As champions of your cause, your board members play a pivotal role in steering your nonprofit toward its mission-driven goals. To equip your board with the tools and insights needed to navigate the complexities of nonprofit governance effectively, we are thrilled to work with Megan Motil and Des Worthington to offer a 5-part in-person lunch and learn series. 


Whether you're a current board member, leadership staff, or simply curious to learn more about nonprofit governance, we invite you to join us for one or all of the upcoming sessions! While each session stands on its own, the series is designed to build upon the content of previous sessions, offering a comprehensive stack of practical strategies tailored to advance your nonprofit's mission. 
April 18: Recruiting the Right Board for Impact
May 2: Aligning Board Roles with Strategic Goals
May 9: Elevating Board Fundraising Engagement 
May 23: Setting Standards for Healthy Board Culture & Behavior


This blog introduces some of the essential concepts that we reviewed with Megan Motil and Des Worthington at the first of our 5-part series on Maximizing Board Effectiveness, which took place on April 10, 2024. Participants in the first workshop, which focused on Adapting Board Roles for Ongoing Success, delved into the life stages of nonprofit organizations and their boards, the non-negotiable duties of nonprofit boards, the importance of role clarity, and an introduction to the RASIC framework. 


Understanding the Lifecycle of Nonprofit Organizations and Their Boards

Have you ever considered that nonprofit organizations, much like living organisms, undergo distinct stages of growth and development? From the inception of an idea to the maturity of a fully-fledged organization, nonprofits progress through stages that profoundly impact their operations and governance structures.


As Megan and Des highlight, it's entirely normal for nonprofit boards to evolve and change over time. Just as organizations progress through distinct life stages—startup, growth, maturity, decline (and renew)—so too do their boards. However, it's essential to ask critical questions about where the organization currently stands, where it aspires to be, and what needs to remain constant or adapt to facilitate growth and development. 


Understanding the unique needs and challenges of each stage is essential for boards and the organizations they serve to thrive. You can gain deeper insights into the development of your organization’s board by using this Organizational Life Stage Self-Assessment tool, provided by Megan Motil of Parallel Solutions. By examining characteristics associated with startup, growth, maturity, and decline life stages, organizations can identify their unique position and envision their trajectory over the next 1-3 years. 


Which descriptors most closely align with your organization's current stage, and where do you envision your organization evolving in the near future?


"Organizations may fall between phases and exhibit characteristics of several stages. Healthy boards self-assess and are open to evolving based on life stage roles, strategic goals, desired outcomes, needs, and strengths," emphasizes Megan.


The Non-Negotiable Duties of Nonprofit Boards

What responsibilities do nonprofit boards carry, and what obligations do board members owe to their organizations and stakeholders?


Nonprofit boards are entrusted with non-negotiable governing roles and duties. 

  • Duty of Care: Legal responsibility to participate actively in making decisions on behalf of the organization and use their best judgment while doing so. 
  • Duty of Loyalty: Each board member must put the interests of the organization before their personal or professional interests.
  • Duty of Obedience: Legal responsibility of ensuring the organization complies with applicable federal, state, and local laws AND adheres to its mission.


These legal and ethical obligations require board members to actively participate in decision-making, prioritize the organization's interests over their own, and ensure compliance with laws, and adherence to the mission. 


Des underscores the importance of clarifying these duties: "Board members are personally and legally responsible for what happens at the organization they serve. It is crucial to define these responsibilities clearly to avoid confusion."


Alongside their governing duties, nonprofit boards may also assume managing roles. To distinguish between these capacities, you can utilize this chart, which outlines the distinct responsibilities of boards in governing and managing roles. This framework is a tool for clarifying lines of authority and decision-making and identifying when board members are responsible for managing roles as a body and when they are working in a delegated individual volunteer capacity related to management activities.


The Importance of Role Clarity

Have you ever experienced confusion or ambiguity regarding your role on a nonprofit board?


Role clarity is not just a matter of organizational efficiency; it's a cornerstone of effective governance. Without clear delineation of roles and expectations, boards risk falling into common role-related challenges including board apathy, confusion about priorities, and difficulty recruiting and retaining board members. When roles and responsibilities are clearly defined, it can foster deeper engagement, more efficient implementation of the mission, effective communication, and build trust both internally and externally.


Megan highlights the significance of role clarity in navigating change and helping to build the conditions for trust: "Role clarity sets the foundation for effective governance and ensures that everyone is aligned and accountable."


The RASIC framework is a powerful tool that empowers organizations to navigate the complexities of roles and responsibilities with precision and clarity. By delineating who is responsible for what, who has the authority to make decisions, and how support, communication, and consultation are structured, the RASIC tool becomes an invaluable resource for fostering deeper engagement, enhancing efficiency, and building trust within and beyond the boardroom.


Recruiting the Right Board for Impact

Looking ahead, how can nonprofit organizations recruit the right board members to drive impact and sustainability?


Join us on April 18 for our next session, Recruiting the Right Board for Impact, we’ll explore some strategies and best practices for building a dynamic and impactful board. By identifying the skills, expertise, and perspectives needed to support the organization's mission, boards can cultivate a diverse and committed group of leaders who are aligned with the organization's values and objectives.


Downloadable Resources:

Organizational Life Stage Self-Assessment

Managing vs Governing Roles

Governance and Decision-Making Authority Worksheet

RASIC Explanation

Sample Board Commitment Letter Using RASIC


Resources Search

Resources Archive